Magnetism

As I alluded to in a previous post, I found a great way to open up some space in the tank. In this hobby there seems to be no shortage of small to medium-sized operations wherein a hobbyist comes up with something marketable and starts selling it. A good example of this is inTank LLC, and Aqua-Mags. I've not yet had the pleasure of using any of inTank's products but many people have with some success. I haven't ruled it out for the future.

Aqua-Mags sells the "Frag-Mag" (and similar "Rock-Mag"), a unique and useful product. It's simple and effective, and really opens up a lot of potential for smaller tanks. Essentially a Frag-Mag is just a couple of strong rare-earth magnets encased in plastic which are attracted to each other on either side of a surface of the aquarium... be it the glass sides or back, plastic false wall, overflow, what-have-you. One of the magnets, on the "aquarium side", is covered in rough gravel to which you can glue or epoxy a frag of coral. In this way the otherwise barren back wall of the aquarium can be occupied  by corals... or whatever else you can imagine.

 
 


I decided to mount my Torch Coral somewhere that would open up some space in the tank as well as provide the torch ample room to expand. Using some D-D ROWA Aquascape Epoxy, I mounted the torch to one side of the Frag-Mag and left it in its usual spot on my rock to cure for 24+ hours. When it was done, I experimented with it in several positions on the back and side walls. I've tentatively chosen the right upper glass for the Torch to stay semi-permanently because it seems to really like the mix of lighting and flow in that spot. It's always fully inflated and healthy-looking. The moderate water flow gives it a constant sweeping movement that catches the eye from across the room. The only downside here is that if someone knocks or removes the outside magnet, the Torch could conceivably fall down against a rock and become damaged and/or sting other corals that it lands on. This was a great opportunity to work with both the epoxy and the Frag-Mag and learn a bit about how quickly it sets, how to shape it, the strength of the magnets, etc.

Here are a few shots when the Torch was mounted on the back wall.
 
 
I feel like having it on the glass lets you see both sides of this animal, and to be able to look at it from underneath isn't a common sight in the hobby.

That left me with two unused Frag-Mags. For a week or so I contemplated what to do with them, finally deciding to act on an idea I had thrown around since the tank was first set up. One of my rocks had always seemed out of place and awkward, and I had a lot of barren space on the back wall of the tank... Why not elevate the rock and mount it up on the wall using Frag-Mags?

First the tank had to be prepared for all of this activity to minimize on potential accidents. I migrated all of the corals to the right side of the tank as closely as possible without touching (don't want to start any wars) and effectively cleared the area I'd be working in. I moved the small rock with the purple clove polyps that was one of my first coral purchases. It had been sitting on the rock that was to be moved, and the coralline growth had stopped at its edges... moving it revealed a white "tan line" on the rock in its place. For the several weeks since introduced, these little polyps had begun to flourish and had finally spread onto the rock itself (one of my original goals).

 All corals relocated away from the construction zone, and a Cerith snail clearly ready for its close-up.

The cyphastrea meteor shower was glued to the rock and could not be removed. Like the few clavularia polyps that had begun to spread to the rock, the meteor shower would have to survive a few minutes of exposure to air while I worked on the epoxy outside the aquarium. A couple quick google searches assured me that it would probably be ok. I suddenly realized something was missing from my plan.....

 
Iverson Merlot from gold country in Northern California set the mood. 
Later on I broke out the Ardbeg 10 year for the victory lap.


I can't emphasize enough how important it is to know your plan ahead of time when doing something like this. Aquascape Epoxy is very unforgiving once it cures. If you screw up, you've ruined your rock and wasted your magnets. I spent several minutes holding the rock against the wall in different positions taking mental notes, determining whether the dividing wall between chamber 2 and 3 would affect the placement of magnets, whether the pump return line would get in the way, etc. It was also important to note exactly where on the rock the magnets would be affixed. Finally and most important, both magnets could be adjusted and moved independently while being attached to the rock, but in their final position they would have to be flush with each other and as coplanar as possible to have the best grip on the flat wall. Here are a couple of pictures that I took while planning the location of the rock and its general orientation on the wall. It was pretty awkward taking these with one free hand.

 


The timing during this process was critical as the epoxy only minutes of pliability before it begins to set. I cut off a generous amount and stuck it in the microwave for a couple of seconds it to make it easier to hand-mix. Then I formed it into two even clumps and carefully pressed it onto the gravel face of the Frag-Mags. I started in the very center and used firm thumb pressure to ensure that the epoxy, which has a clay-like consistency before curing, formed a strong bond to the gravel. There was a lot of rushing but I managed to get it all done with a few minutes to spare- now came the more nerve-wracking part. I took the piece of rock out of the tank and gently patted dry the portion where the epoxy would bond. The two magnets were pressed onto the porous dead-coral surface and I spread the epoxy as far as possible in all directions, especially into crevices and around corners so that it would have a strong hold once cured. After both magnets were attached, I put the rock magnet-side down on the flat table surface and dropped my eye-level, adjusting the magnets' positions individually until they rested flush with each other against the tabletop. Each adjustment of the magnets meant more pressing and forming of the epoxy. At one point I re-dipped the side of the rock to keep it and the coral wet. The whole process took a few minutes and the epoxy had clearly begun to set by the time I finished.

 
Gathered proper supplies, set my working area up.

 
Guesstimated the proper amount of epoxy for this project. I usually cut this size into smaller pieces and microwave them for a few seconds, to make mixing easier.

 
Here's a shot before I started to even out the magnet surfaces and make them flush.

 
It was a harrowing experience trying to get this right while minimizing the coral and rock's exposure to air. Excuse the poor photo quality here, but I was essentially using the tabletop to get the magnet surfaces flush. After pressing them in, I would smooth out the epoxy a bit more on the coral, and then repeat the process.

 
In the above two photos you can see the rock returned to the tank with magnets attached. I used the drip tray to ensure that they stayed flush. Might have been unnecessary, but it certainly didn't hurt anything.


I returned the rock to the tank in a corner away from all of the corals. The unused grate from the bottom of chamber two served as a temporary spacer and a somewhat rigid, flat surface to make sure that the magnets stayed flush while the epoxy cured... which took two days. After a long wait, during which my tank appeared to be in total upheaval, it was time to see how my handiwork had turned out... success!

 
 


This method worked so well that I am already thinking about a sequel. When and if I find a suitable rock, I am going to mount it across the back wall from the far right to the middle (from under the Koralia and behind the Frogspawn). On that rock I will and grow some Green Star Polyps or a clavularia species. There are some really nice ones.  I think it would provide some more depth and motion to the tank.

On a sad note, the tragedy I mentioned in the last post was the death of my Randall's Goby only a week before it was reintroduced to the aquarium. I don't know the cause of death- the hospital tank water tested fine and it was eating (ravenously) up to the day of its death. No signs of disease or injury. Could it have simply not gotten enough food? It didn't seem thin. That goby was pretty entertaining and I was planning on matching it with a pistol shrimp eventually, so I was bummed out by the loss. I despise failure, and especially failure without explanation. While it was an expensive and disheartening loss, the bright side is now I have the opportunity to choose another fish to replace him. This weekend at the the store I saw what I can only assume was a fully-grown Randall's Goby and it was HUGE! Seeing their full size has convinced me to go with a much smaller shrimp goby, something like a Stonogobiops Yasha which only reaches two inches, or maybe a bit more. That's far less bioload than the monstrous Randall's that I saw over the weekend, and it affords me more flexibility in choosing additional bioload while still providing a colorful addition and the interesting shrimp-goby relationship that I'll get into at some other time.

Stomatella Love

Wow. I've read about this but didn't think I would be lucky enough to see it in action anytime soon. Stomatella Snails are some of the more common hitchhikers that are introduced to tanks via live rock and coral purchases, and they are one of the few snails that seem to readily and successfully reproduce in an aquarium. Many other snail species will attempt to spawn but have extended planktonic larval stages which cannot survive in such a closed environment.

Stomatellas breed via broadcast- in an organized fashion brought on by some sort of chemical signal, all of the snails in the tank will simultaneously clime up to a high point on the rock and release their eggs and sperm into the water column, and the rest is up to nature. Given that only a few months ago I had two of these snails and now there are twenty or thirty of them in my tank, this must have been going on for some time.

Anyway a few minutes ago I was lucky enough to be sitting in front of the tank and looking at the curious puffs of smoke rising from my rock. I soon realized what was going on... not a minute later the female stomatellas began releasing hundreds of eggs through their breathing siphons. I was too fascinated to pick up the camera, but next time I will definitely try to capture this in images.

Many of these eggs become food for other animals in the tank but judging by the present population there are plenty that make it to adulthood.

I also found my first starfish tonight. Not exactly sure which species it is but it appears to be of the genus Asterina, and is about 5-8mm wide. There are some scattered accounts of these animals eating the base of Acropora hard corals but the general consensus is that they're welcome additions unless they reach plague proportions.

Skimming the Surface

Since back when I was working on the initial planning for this reef system, the use of protein skimming was something of an expensive option in the realm of filtration and water quality. Initially the feeling was that I could get by without using a protein skimmer. Not only are they usually quite expensive but finding one that will fit in the back of my Oceanic Biocube29 limits the selection to only a few models which are designed specifically for nano reefs.

Protein skimmers are designed to remove dissolved organic compounds (DOCs) from water before they decompose by means of a principle called Foam Fractionation. These compounds are hydrophobic or hydrophilic, or both- that is, they repel or are attracted to water, respectively. In a water molecule, the two Hydrogen atoms lend a slightly positive charge while the Oxygen atom slightly negative. The nonlinear arrangement of the water molecule gives it a slight electric dipole moment; we can also say water molecules are dipolar (non-polar molecules tend to be hydrophobic). The dipolar property of water is actually the basis for some of its most important and unique features, but I digress... the point is, many of the undesirable compounds in the tank, due to their hydrophobic character, readily "stick" to a surface between water and air.

Foam Fractionation involves the creation of many tiny bubbles to create a vast amount of surface area between water and air. These bubbles are created by various means (venturi pressure, spinning needle-wheel, airstone, etc) and confined within the body of the skimmer. Tank water passes through the base of the skimmer, and when a hydrophobic or partially hydrophobic molecule (as well as some types of particulate matter) meets this interface between the air and water (a bubble), it gets stuck, becoming bound to the bubble surface. The only way up and out for these bubbles is through the columnar opening of a collection cup which sits on top of the skimmer. As the bubbles collect an increasing amount of material, they become more frothy and disgusting... eventually reaching the top of the column and spilling over into the collection cup. This overflowing gunk is called the "skimmate"; that which was skimmed, I suppose. One may choose to "skim wet" or "skim dry", the difference being the amount of water removed with the skimmate. This is a direct result of the amount of bubble production and water surface height within the column. Skimming dry produces a nasty, stinky sludge in the collection cup but does not remove as much as skimming wet, which produces a steady amount of tea-colored liquid. The latter typically removes more DOCs but at the cost of also removing salt water, complicating top-offs because the water level fluctuation is no longer due to evaporation alone. Maintaining a strictly constant salinity is a little more difficult with aggressive skimming in a small tank like mine.

Two things determine the quality of a skimmer: (1) greater surface area between water and bubbles, and (2) contact time between the water and air. This is why larger, taller skimmers that produce a greater amount of smaller bubbles do the best.

Long story short, I had decided to buy and use a skimmer. Reading the countless reviews, testimonials, and personal experiences out there convinced me that the best one on the market for a Biocube29 is a Tunze Nano 9002 DOC Protein Skimmer. I asked my friend about his experience with them... as it turned out, he had one that was unused and was willing to lend it to me before I made my decision on whether to invest. This was great news... that very night I went home and disassembled, cleaned, studied, and reassembled it. It's actually quite a simple design but is very effective. It uses a venturi pump to produce bubbles; the aperture can be controlled using the small blue screw at the top of the chamber.


 
 


As most other Biocube owners have experienced, there is only really one option for placement of this skimmer: chamber 2. This entire chamber formerly served as my refugium, lit on a reverse-day cycle to grow chaetomorpha. I also used the drip tray to support a piece of filter floss which catches particulate in the overflow from chamber 1. Pictures of this are visible a couple of posts prior to this. Placing the Tunze in this chamber seemed problematic with a bunch of loose macroalgae tumbling around in the water. I didn't want the pump intake clogged with loose algae and the skimmer takes up more than half of the chamber, so I temporarily removed all of the algae until coming up with a suitable solution. My chaetomorpha happily lived in a separate bowl of tank water for a few days. The couple of unfortunate amphipods that migrated into the bowl with it were eventually fed to my fish who are still in the hospital tank.

The stock collection cup on the Tunze 9002 is, in my opinion, unnecessarily large for the profile of the skimmer itself. Its diameter exceeds the width of the back opening of my hood and the width of the back chamber. Some modifications to the tank and to the hood were needed so that I could easily remove the cup for periodic emptying. Out came the utility knife, heavy-duty scissors, and wire cutters. There are some alternatives and custom 3rd party accessories for the biocube which are meant to work in conjunction with the Tunze 9002, but I decided to just mod the tank for now. None of my proposed changes affected the outside aesthetic of the tank hood.


 
Slots cut out of the hood so that the cup can be removed with ease. They aren't apparent when the lid is closed.

 
The cord is extremely short. I had to add another power strip in the top shelf and cut a space make a shorter path from the skimmer to the plug.


I needed a way to get my chaetomorpha back inside chamber 2, protected and confined to a single area where it could be illuminated at night for growth but without risk of being sucked up into the skimmer. Even though the skimmer removes many of the nutrients that would otherwise decompose and be used by the chaetomorpha, it doesn't hurt to have additional means of removing phosphates and nitrates as they inevitably build up (the main method being regular water changes). The chaetomorpha is also handy for providing an environment where pods and other animals can thrive and reproduce. One of my concerns with a skimmer is that using it would suck up many of the pods that had been living and reproducing in chamber two, but judging by the frighteningly overwhelming population in the main tank I don't think they need much help reproducing. I thought about this at length and tried to come up with a home-made solution that would provide the same functionality as some of the pre-built 3rd party modifications.

For $3.99 I bought a clear, cylindrical plastic spray bottle at the supermarket that looked like it would fit next to the skimmer in chamber 2. Using the utility knife, I carefully started three rings of holes around the base of the bottle and progressively opened them until I could punch a small nail through each. I followed up with a much larger nail to open the holes to the desired final diameter, and tested the flow through these holes in my kitchen sink. Even with the water blasting into the opening of the bottle, the water level did not reach a couple inches higher than the top ring of holes- water flowed very quickly through the bottle. This is what I wanted. The mass of chaetomorpha could sit at the bottom of the bottle, lit up from behind the tank by my JBJ Nano Glo, with water flowing down from the top of the bottle to keep the spaghetti-like clump from dispersing and to provide necessary nutrients to the macroalgae. I opened up the top of the bottle so that water could easily pour in. Instead of cutting the top off completely, I carefully snipped a circular hole along the top to retain much of the strength of the thick plastic that the manufacturers used. It turned out really well, at least as an interim solution until I get a custom-fit media basket.

 
  
  
  
  
  

  
Bottle in place.

A view through the window on the back of the tank with the Nano-Glo on. I've since adjusted the height of the light and the bottle so it hits the algae more directly.

With the skimmer in place, the drip tray that had previously taken up all of the top of chamber two had to be cut down to size. I tried several versions of this reduced form and finally settled on cutting the thing entirely in half, also removing the raised plastic in the middle so that the filter floss would sit lower in the flow of water from chamber 1. As you can see in the pictures below, the glass side of chamber 2 (the back) did not have a support so I used one of the extra sucker pads from my Maxijet 1200 (the pump I use for water changes) to support it.


 

 
 
 


This set of modifications effectively provides the same mechanical filtration as I had before, keeps my chaetomorpha in one place, more effectively utilizes the light from the nano-glo, and makes room for the skimmer- which is an extremely useful means of removing tank pollutants and waste products before they even begin to decompose. I think a skimmer is probably the single best investment you can make with regards to water quality in a reef tank. Within a few hours it was already producing results:


 


All said and done, the corals and other livestock will be happier with the improvement in water quality, even though Zoanthids and some other LPS prefer to have some dissolved nutrients in the water; that shouldn't be a problem. The water is a already much clearer after only a few days of skimming and a healthy amount of frothing, bubbling spillover fills the collection cup with a tea colored cup of gunk every few days... gunk that would otherwise be floating around in the tank and yellowing my water.

I mounted two LED-based lights within the tank stand. It's much easier to work in there now, especially on any electrical wiring.



 

That's all until for now. My fish will be reintroduced to the tank next Friday after a long fallow period to clear the tank of any possible marine ich. Couple of new corals in the next update, a novel placement of my torch, and a tragedy to report.

Of Snails and Corals

Where to start...

The largest five (out of eight) hermit crabs were turned in to my LFS for store credit, along with five bumblebee Snails which were only in my tank for one day. I was getting tired of the raucous gang of hermits scurrying over corals, picking on each other, harassing snails, and generally being antagonists. The small ones are still handy to have around and they're interesting, but I don't need that many.

The bumblebee snails were a last-resort decision. My LFS had limited snail selection and I wanted to step up the snail population from the two Mexican Turbos and several Stomatella snails, the latter of which came in on my live rock and are now steadily multiplying. Upon further research, though, I read some anecdotal accounts about the Bumblebee snails that I didn't like. They are opportunistic predators (like the hermit crabs, and more so than most other species of reef-safe snails) and can devastate the microfauna in the sand bed with the same gusto that they will consume algae. I felt that I had to watch them carefully and decided to do some serious research on the type of snails available to the modern day reef keeper.

Cerith snails seem to be the most handy snails to have around. Their eating habits revolve around nuisance algae, diatoms, and things you generally want gone. They can usually right themselves when turned over (a big deal compared to other types of snails), are largely peaceful, and come from warmer climates. Unfortunately it takes several of them to eat at the same rate as even one medium sized Turbo, and they are not as good at removing uneaten food and detritus as they are at scraping algae off of the glass and rocks. After finding them at another local fish store, I added six Ceriths to my tank. They're easily distinguishable by their sharply conical shells... you frequently see hermit crabs in these same shells.




My plan in the next couple of weeks, roughly coinciding with the reintroduction of my fish to the tank from quarantine, is to try to obtain the following: (3) Trochus Snails, (2) Nassarius Snails, and (2) Nerite Snails. Each species is slightly different in its habits, diet, capacity to dig/stir the sandbed, etc. My guess is that it's best to have a mix.

Several corals have been added... I am now holding off on getting any more. I just don't have any room to spare in the near future, especially considering the growth potential of the corals I already have. The Euphyllia species are real-estate intensive for a 29 gallon cube; they can grow rather large, taking up roughly the space of a basketball if left to grow. That said, I do have some plans in the works that will open up a lot of space in my tank. At that point there will be some options for new coral and I will be extremely choosy! More on that plan later, but it has been set in motion.

Pulsing Xenia (Xenia umbellata) - My mom gave me a very great Christmas gift this year... she picked out a colony of Pulsing Xenia  from and bought it for me to be picked up later. I had noticed this specific colony on prior visits and it was the most active "pulsing" colony in the store. I brought it home (30 minute drive) and immediately started a gentle acclimation process. Since the colony was growing on some egg crate (the shop actually "fragged" the egg crate for me)  I bought a bit of live rock to which I glued the Xenia. Since I haven't been able to take a decent picture of this coral, you'll have to wait to see it.

Craiglist has proven to be quite a good source of cheap, quality corals. I met a couple people over the last week who were genuinely passionate about the hobby and talked with me at length about their setups. It's really nice meeting these guys and discussing livestock, hardware, etc. Some of them belong to the Bay Area Reefers (a reef keeping club that meets in Fremont) and have urged me to come along to the next meeting. In any case, on one of my visits I was particularly intrigued by a Christmas Favia (Favia sp.) frag that had many eyes on it for $25. In a store this might cost me double that, and I had the pleasure of dealing with someone who grew, fragged, and cared for the coral himself. This Christmas Favia is a green with red coloration on the polyps. Favia is a strong stinger and can't really be kept in close proximity to anything else. It does readily accept meaty meals and will swallow whole any mysis I can place near its mouths. The bottom part of it, as you can see in the photo, has a couple of skeletal polyps; the previous owner suggested that it had been stung by another coral. Most corals, if healthy, will simply regrow over dead spots like this.



Christmas Favia eating mysis.

I was lucky enough to obtain frags from two different colonies of Green birds nest (Seriatopora guttatus). I think one of them is the same as the ORA lineage, which looks tremendous under the proper lighting- this one came from another Craigslist contact. The other came gratis from my LFS; another generous gift of several frags from his show tank colony. This colony isn't fully colored up with the fluorescent neon green polyps but a lot of that depends on lighting and health conditions.


 
 


The frag that I got from my craigslist contact went through an rigorous iodide (or iodine?) dip which was probably lasted too long; the frag is not thriving and has some dead sections. Iodine dips are common practice; they can potentially irritate the coral but at the proper duration and concentration, they mainly serve to "stun" and dislodge any attached animals from the frag or plug. This includes a lot of beneficial creatures, but it is mainly to knock off any possible parasites or pests that are lodged on the coral. Whenever you get a coral from an unfamiliar source, its a good idea to dip with iodine, just as you would quarantine (or in addition to quarantine).

I added another Euphyllia to the collection, right next to my Frogspawn. The Torch coral (Euphyllia glabrescens) comes in various color morphs- I chose one with translucent white polyps tipped in an opaque white. This colony looked extremely healthy at the LFS over the course of a couple of weeks... I had noticed it on previous visits (another benefit of frequent visits to the fish store) and never saw it with a problem. Buying new arrivals in the Euphyllia species can be problematic; these are stony corals and their skeletons are very sharp. During transport the delicate polyp tissue is almost always damaged. A completely unharmed Torch, Hammer, or Frogspawn coral after shipping is nearly unheard of. Placing the coral illustrates an exception to the usual "don't let corals touch each other" rule- Euphyllia species, much like zoanthids, can come into contact with other corals within the same genus and not sting each one another. That's good, because otherwise I would have to give them both a lot more room. I plan on eventually doing something interesting with this frag. It didn't come with a piece of rock, so it is wedged in a crevice for now. I knocked it over once during maintenance and felt pretty bad. Fortunately it wasn't damaged. The torch is a very dynamic coral that adds a lot of movement to the tank. You can see from these pictures how much it changes from one moment to the next.







Another great craigslist find were several species of Zoanthids that I picked up from a hobbyist who was propagating and fragging them for pretty reasonable prices. At present, I have counted the following "named" zoas in my collection: Fire & Ice, Bam Bam Orange, Eye of Ra, Eagle Eyes, and Tub's Blues. I've also been able to identify some of my existing Zoas- Bird of Prey. Below are the new zoas on their plugs. After a few days of getting used to the new tank they were all fully open and I'll soon begin gluing them to my developing zoa colony garden.


Tub's Blue and some Eagle Eyes


Fire & Ice, Tub's Blues, and Eagle Eyes

Eye of Ra, Bam Bam Orange

Four colorful, half-inch crustaceans have been perched on various corals for the past few days- when they meet each other or when they are frightened, they wave their butts around in conspicuous circles and make no apparent effort to disguise themselves. These are Sexy Shrimp (Thor amboinensis).


Chilling on my Ricordea
 
Hanging out underneath the torch
 
Relaxing on the lobo open brain

 
Poised and ready to steal food from the coral at first opportunity


Yes... that is what they are called. They don't grow much larger than their current size at an inch or so. Widely considered reef-safe, they will in fact resort to eating soft corals if they don't get enough food. Sexy shrimp are very peaceful and passive reef inhabitants and do well in groups. Some people swear by "odd numbered groups" but I cant imagine why. In any case, I never see more than two or three of them in any one place. They do definitely benefit from interacting with each other and my feeling is on their own they would not do as well as with others. These are often the first animals in the tank to get Ooohs and (especially) Awwws. Their seductive, gyrating dance is enough to get the attention of even the least observant viewer. Sexy shrimp are also known as Anemone Shrimp because they bond or host with anemones in the wild. In the tank they'll host on anything that resembles an anemone and are highly promiscuous about the various corals on which they will perch. I am going to try keeping them very well fed so that they are never tempted to munch on my zoas or LPS. So far there have been intermittent incidents and the jury is still out on whether I'll let these guys stay for the long term. They're frequently perched on my brain coral and I even saw one audacious individual reaching down into one of the mouths of the coral, hopefully in search of food and not having found a snack of Lobophyllia innards. When the fish are reintroduced there will be more food for them in the tank and this habit may go away.

That's it for livestock, but there is big hardware news coming up.

Here are a few more bonus pics that turned out well: